Short answer: Yes, if they exist. In a lawsuit, the other side can ask for any relevant, non-privileged document in your "possession, custody, or control", and a saved AI chat is a document. A subpoena can also go to the AI vendor for whatever it stores. In February 2026 a federal judge in New York held that a defendant's chats with Claude, a publicly available AI tool, were not protected by attorney-client privilege. So the practical questions are what your AI tool keeps, for how long, and what you must preserve once a dispute is on the horizon.
Why this comes up on deals
Deals produce disputes: earnout fights, indemnity claims, claims that a seller hid a problem, and regulator questions about trading ahead of an announcement. In each one, the other side may ask for what the deal team wrote at the time. Today that includes what the team asked an AI tool about the target, and what it answered.
What discovery can reach
Under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, "Parties may obtain discovery regarding any nonprivileged matter that is relevant to any party's claim or defense and proportional to the needs of the case" (Rule 26(b)(1)). A party can be asked to produce items "in the responding party's possession, custody, or control", including "electronically stored information" (Rule 34(a)). State courts have similar rules.
That reaches AI in two ways:
- From you. Chats your firm can see or export, and anything you downloaded or pasted into a memo.
- From the vendor. Whatever the vendor stores can be the subject of a subpoena served on the vendor.
Are AI chats privileged?
Not automatically. In United States v. Heppner (S.D.N.Y., opinion filed February 17, 2026), Judge Rakoff held that a defendant's documents recording his chats with Claude were protected by neither attorney-client privilege nor the work product doctrine (opinion). Two reasons matter for deal teams:
- "Because Claude is not an attorney, ... that alone disposes of Heppner's claim of privilege."
- The chats "were not confidential", in part because the consumer privacy policy said Anthropic could "disclose personal data to third parties in connection with claims, disputes[,] or litigation."
This was one judge in one district, on the publicly available version of Claude under its consumer privacy policy, and commentators disagree with parts of it (Harvard Law Review blog). We found no ruling yet on business plans. But the safe assumption for a deal team is that AI chats are ordinary business documents.
How can I ensure my communications with my lawyer stay confidential?
Talk or write to your lawyer directly, and keep your questions about the legal matter out of public AI tools unless your lawyer has approved the tool and the use. That is the practical lesson of Heppner. In a footnote, the court said that "even if certain information that Heppner input into Claude was privileged, he waived the privilege by sharing that information with Claude and Anthropic, just as if he had shared it with any other third party." It also held that chats which were not privileged to begin with did not become privileged when he later shared them with his lawyers. The judge left one door open: "Had counsel directed Heppner to use Claude, Claude might arguably be said to have functioned in a manner akin to a highly trained professional who may act as a lawyer's agent within the protection of the attorney-client privilege." So if you want to use AI on a legal question about a deal, ask your deal counsel first and let them choose the tool. For the lawyer's side of the question, see AI and attorney-client privilege on AI Ethics for Lawyers.
Can a court order a vendor to keep chats?
It has happened. In the New York Times lawsuit against OpenAI, a court order required OpenAI to keep consumer ChatGPT and API content. OpenAI says "Our obligations under the earlier order ended on September 26, 2025", and that it still stores "limited historical" user data from April to September 2025 for the case. It also says the order did not affect ChatGPT Enterprise or Edu customers (OpenAI). The order is over, but it shows that stored chats can be held for litigation the user is not part of.
Your own duty to preserve
This is the part a tool cannot do for you. Once litigation is reasonably expected, you have to keep relevant information, including electronic information. Under Rule 37(e), if information "that should have been preserved in the anticipation or conduct of litigation is lost because a party failed to take reasonable steps to preserve it", a court can order measures to cure the harm, and if the party "acted with the intent to deprive another party of the information's use in the litigation", it can presume the information was unfavorable (Rule 37).
So a tool that keeps nothing cuts what exists to be requested in the ordinary course. It does not let you delete material after a legal hold applies. When counsel issues a hold, follow it, whatever tool you use.
How the common tools compare
| Tool | What exists to be requested | Source |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT Business or Enterprise | Stored chats, until deleted; deleted chats removed within 30 days "unless we are legally required to retain them" | OpenAI |
| Claude Enterprise | Chats and projects; "By default, data is retained indefinitely unless a custom retention period is set" | Anthropic |
| Microsoft 365 Copilot | "The stored data includes the user's prompt and Copilot's response"; admins can find it with Content search or Microsoft Purview | Microsoft |
| Faradex | Faradex can be subpoenaed like any U.S. company. Files and conversations are held in memory, with no backups, so Faradex has no stored copy of your work to hand over. Anything you download is yours, and discoverable from you. | Faradex |
What a deal team should do
- Assume every AI chat about a deal could be read by the other side in a later dispute. Write prompts the way you would write an email.
- Know what your tool keeps, and set the shortest retention that still meets your own record-keeping duties (see the investment banking page for broker-dealers).
- Keep privileged legal advice out of general AI tools unless counsel has approved the tool and the use.
- When a legal hold arrives, tell everyone on the deal, and do not delete or reset anything it covers.